September 21, 2007

Buzz about the beds

ADVenture: A weekly column examining popular advertising campaigns.

The product: Mattresses at Ikea

The ad campaign: Ikea has launched an ad campaign which has a variety of different kinds of ads designed for TV, radio, print (newspapers and magazines), a micro-site on their web page and a guerrilla marketing stunt to create buzz about their mattresses.

The stunt involved having people sleeping (or trying to) on Ikea mattresses all over downtown Toronto in a one-day event this fall. The micro site offers our first view of the Ikea guy, who until now has merely been a voice.

The rationale:

"A lot of people don’t realize that we do have a mattress program and we wanted to address the misconception that we only have European sizes (which we haven’t had for 15 years).

This is the first time we have tried using (Ikea guy’s) likeness. It’s that brand recognition that comes with his voice. He will not have a name. You don’t want the attention to be on the personality, you want it to be on the product. "

- Madeleine Lowenborg-Frick, Ikea spokesperson

Creative ad agency: Zig, Toronto and Trapeze (Toronto) for the micro-site

The chat:

"I am a big advocate of buzz marketing (or word-of-mouth marketing - tactics employed to get consumers talking - including guerrilla marketing). When brand communications come from another consumer (as opposed to brand advertising), the message is more credible and often more relevant.

"What I especially like about this campaign, though, is the multi-media, multi-tactic approach. The guerrilla marketing mattresses-on-the-street exploit wasn’t a one-off. It was integrated with similar messages across other media.

"Kudos to Ikea. It is common sense, but shamefully uncommon for marketers to create campaigns that are truly integrated. The tone of the message is irreverent, quirky and helpful-consistent with Ikea’s brand image, and interestingly, yet consistently communicated across their print advertising, television spots, their website, etc.

"

I think I like (the Ikea guy). I wonder if consumers will want to get to know him better … what is his name? And can I send him my sleep-related questions?

The other option would have been for Ikea to simply announce, "We sell mattresses too!". Instead, they chose to focus on a true consumer benefit-helping consumers sleep better. This may be the ideal positioning for them, in the short term at least. I wonder if the "sleep coach"

positioning may be difficult to own in a marketplace where some competitors focus exclusively on mattresses. I also wonder … how long does it take to assemble an Ikea mattress?

"

- Andrea Wojnicki, assistant professor of marketing, Rotman School of Business, University of Toronto

"I think that to appreciate what Ikea has done here, you have to first appreciate the size of the challenge they’ve given themselves.

"Mattresses are mostly a commodity product, save for perhaps one market dominant retail brand that positions itself as specialized. That’s a tough market to break into because you’re going to be hard pressed to make money attacking the commodity end of the market and hard pressed to be taken seriously against a brand like Sleep Country.

"Whatever Ikea may stand for in the fevered minds of its agency or in the sanctity of its boardroom, to the consumer it’

s cheap home décor. Its brand stands for some alloy of design and value, two things that are essentially irrelevant to the bed business and it

’s tough to imagine beating Leon’s ‘No Payments Until The Apocalypse’ pricing.

Given all of that, they did everything right. They chose to position themselves as experts, the most likely of the two difficult options. They fought the established competitive brand with substantial information.

"The guerrilla marketing day was a smart move, where so often these things are just meant to gratify the marketer. Because this initiative was in some sense off-brand for Ikea, they had to demand attention.

"The danger in trying to take a brand into new positioning territory is that you could lose the brand in the process. The Ikea guy is plainly meant to be continuity, designed to recall and connect with whatever good feelings you might have about the brand.

"All in all, a smart, thoughtful, grown-up effort."

- Bruce Philp, Brand Engineering, Toronto

September 11, 2007

Welcome

Welcome to those of you caught up in the art of the sell, or in the venture of selling something through advertising. Check out our chatter. Better yet, join in. What do you think of these ads? Do they really sell? What do you think of our panelist's views? If you agree, say so, if don't, same deal.

Lisa Marr

Hamilton Spectator

August 31, 2007

Staples has ad buttoned up

Easybutton The product:
Staples’ Back to school ad campaign with its Easy Button slogan

The ad:
Two dads are barbecuing together in a backyard and one dad asks the other what the Easy Button is for. The one dad hits it, the song The Most Wonderful Time of the Year starts to play and suddenly two teenagers at the side of the pool are dressed in back-to-school gear with supplies on their laps, not looking happy. The ad ends with “That was easy.” (This is a new version of last year’s Most Wonderful time of the Year campaign which saw two parents dancing in the aisles at Staples).

The rationale:
Sandy Salmon at Staples Canada said “We pretty much own that so we didn’t want to lose it. That campaign is the one that got the most recall ever. “The father hits the (Easy) Button and the kids are ready for back-to-school. The message is that it’s easy. That’s what came through loud and clear and that’s what our focus groups said. The ad intends to create the idea that Staples “has every thing you need, it’s easy, and it is the most wonderful time of the year.”
Creative ad agency: MacLaren McCann

The chat:
“The first ad showing a barbecue and a parent bringing the child joys of summer to an end with a push of the “easy button” is consistent with ads from earlier years. Advertising is sometimes called “marketing communication” and to be effective communication needs a central message. One piece of advice experts give companies is to not keep changing its message with each new campaign. Instead, the idea is to build on earlier messages to keep a consistent them running. There have been more than 100 “PC vs. Mac” ads and while each commercial is different, the messages embedded in the ads have been consistent.  The ad is clear and effective.
— Marvin Ryder, McMaster marketing professor

“The original ‘Most Wonderful Time of the Year’ ad was a brilliant piece of laugh-out-loud, funny-cuz-it’s-true television, constructed, as great advertising always is, on an authentic insight about the people whose money you want. But it wasn’t great advertising.  Why? Because it didn’t have its own point of view. It was merely reporting. “There was an inference that you could get your school supplies at Staples … but there was no sense of how this brand, and therefore this retail experience, was going to add any value. The (new) Easy Button spot is pretty darned good, from a branding standpoint and important progress in the Staples campaign. It’s still funny, though not maybe as funny as the original, but it does a couple of new, important things. The most important one is that the brand (in the form of the Button) is now the catalyst for what happens in the spot rather than just being a passive observer. It (also) builds on the parental empathy the original spot got so right, except now (the Button again) that empathy turns into customer empowerment.  That is the difference between an ad that makes people nod and laugh and an ad that makes people want to buy something.
— Bruce Philip, Brand Engineering, Toronto

By Lisa Marr
lmarr@thespec.com

905-526-3992

 

Welcome to AD venture

The business department of the Hamilton Spectator regularly tours marketing strategies. We invite you to comment on this blog.